Eastern Star Temple to Hyatt House Midtown: A Landmark Transformation

Case Study | At a glance

Midtown Sacramento · Historic Adaptive Reuse · Listing Representation & Buyer Sourcing

The transformation of 2719 K Street is a flagship example of adaptive reuse in Midtown Sacramento. Built in 1928 as a lodge for the Order of the Eastern Star with Romanesque Revival architecture, the historic building sat vacant for many years before being reimagined as the 128-room Hyatt House Sacramento/Midtown, with the new Star Lounge on the third floor overlooking Sutter’s Fort State Historic Park.


The approximately $38 million redevelopment gave a long-underutilized landmark a new purpose, combining historic preservation with a modern hospitality use. For Principal Broker Brian Jacks, the transaction also reflects an important part of commercial real estate: recognizing potential in a property and building the relationships that help move an opportunity forward.

Deal Snapshot

  • Property: Historic Eastern Star Temple
  • Location: 2719 K Street, Midtown Sacramento
  • Year built: 1928
  • Original building: Approximately 31,500 square feet across 3 levels
  • Architecture style: Romanesque Revival
  • Redeveloped property: Approximately 86,000 square feet across 8 stories
  • Total project investment: Approximately $38 million
  • Completed use: 128-room extended-stay Hyatt House Hotel and Star Lounge
  • Jacks’ role: Listing representation and buyer sourcing

The Opportunity: How One Deal Led to a Midtown Landmark

Sometimes, the most impactful deals come from the most unexpected of places.

Through a previous project, Jacks had become acquainted with the landlord of the former Rick’s Dessert Diner restaurant space in Midtown. After replacing that tenant with a barbecue restaurateur, the successful business relationship led to a sale listing of the Eastern Star: a 31,500-square-foot historic building across from Sutter’s Fort, also in Midtown.

Jacks has built his brokerage practice around these kinds of relationships and a willingness to work across property types and deal sizes. As he puts it:

“I tend to gravitate towards underdog tenants. I welcome leads from multiple sources and actually prefer the diversity of product type and clientele. Much of the time, one deal leads to another through related exposure.”

Already active in Midtown and with a knack for championing unique properties, The Eastern Star Temple was exactly the kind of listing Jacks was eager to take on.

In the Media

The Eastern Star project was covered extensively by the Sacramento Business Journal, including the original lease announcement, renovation stories, and a feature on the Ghost Hunter team that came to investigate the building while it was still on the market.

Eastern Star and Veterans Memorial Hall | Original Construction

The building originally served as a Masonic lodge and was recognized for its distinctive architecture and historical significance–but its long vacancy and unreinforced masonry construction made redevelopment a complicated proposition.

Finding the right buyer meant identifying an investor who believed in what the property could become.

Jacks, it turns out, was uniquely up to the task of championing a creative reuse future for the Midtown landmark. In 2019, Jacks also facilitated the sale of a second historic landmark in Vallejo: Veterans Memorial Hall. The two buildings shared a striking number of similarities. Both were designed by the same architect, measured approximately 31,500 square feet across three levels, and were built just one year apart. Their escrows closed less than two weeks apart, connecting two historic properties with very different futures.

Jacks saw the potential in both these properties, and seized the opportunity to help set the stage for the next chapter.

The Challenge: Bringing New Life to a Historic Property

Built in 1928, the Eastern Star Temple, listed on the National Registry of Historic Places, originally housed a beautiful lobby, fellowship hall, lodge rooms and an auditorium (grand ball room) on the top floor. Its historic architecture and location gave it distinctive prominence in Midtown and was well known by locals, who frequented the building for special events, such as weddings, graduations and community events.

The Order of the Eastern Star ultimately sold the property when they could no longer keep up with the cost of building expenses and membership numbers declined. A local investor, having already collected numerous commercial properties in Midtown since the 1980’s, saw the opportunity and pounced with a cash offer and quick close.
Due to the building’s configuration, it was not easy to imagine what the building could become next and what it would take to get there. When the idea of a hotel conversion with additional floors was first pitched by the new owner, many would-be investors and even a City councilman said it couldn’t be done.

Historical image of Eastern Star building next to rendering of hotel rennovation in Midtown Sacramento
Eastern Star Historic Star Lounge and historic image of Sutter's Fort accross K Street

Six years later, a local developer with significant experience with smaller adaptive re-use projects in Southern California decided to acquire the former temple and convert it to an extended-stay hotel located directly across from Sutter Hospital. 

Although formally representing the seller for the sale transaction, Jacks also worked closely with the buyer to negotiate terms and navigate the escrow process, which required significant time due to necessary hearings held by the City of Sacramento Preservation Department. 

The buyer oversaw a three year redevelopment to transform the former temple into an extended-stay hotel by converting the original three floors to five levels, plus adding three more levels above. The project required a coordinated effort to address structural challenges, preserve historic elements, and introduce a viable modern use.

The completed Hyatt House Sacramento/Midtown brings new activity to the K Street corridor while retaining elements of the original design, such as  the restored entry, historic lobby, grand staircase, and historical displays that help maintain a connection to the property’s past.

On the third floor, the Star Lounge offers locals and visitors a place to experience the building’s history over food and drinks, with views toward Sutter’s Fort State Historic Park.

Beyond the Transaction

The value of a project like this extends far beyond the property itself. The redevelopment returned a long-vacant local treasure to active use, added a hospitality destination to Midtown, and brought new life to the area.

The redevelopment gave a long-vacant property a productive role in the neighborhood once again, while maintaining the history and character that makes the neighborhood unique. By championing reuse projects, investors can breathe new life into historic neighborhoods, attract visitors, and create new reasons for people to spend time in the area.

Project Impact

  • Approximately $38 million in total project investment
  • 128 hotel rooms serving visitors, business travelers, and extended-stay guests
  • Construction and specialty-trade employment during redevelopment
  • Permanent hospitality and operations jobs following opening
  • Expansion of Sacramento’s visitor economy through transient occupancy tax revenue
  • Additional activity along K Street, near Sutter’s Fort and Midtown’s established business and medical districts

The Jacks Way

The Eastern Star Temple transaction is a flagship example of Jacks’ approach to commercial real estate: build relationships, understand the opportunity, and connect the right people with the right property at the right time.


Not every deal begins with a landmark building or a multimillion-dollar redevelopment. Sometimes, one relationship leads to another. A smaller transaction can open the door to a much larger opportunity—and the significance of a deal is not always measured by its size, but its impact on people and place. In this case, the Easter Star was Jacks’ second commercial real estate transaction with ownership that ultimately led to 15 closed deals over the next seven years.

With more than 30 years of commercial real estate lending and brokerage experience, Brian Jacks offers both a financial perspective and personal approach to his clients. The assignment for the Eastern Star Temple was to represent ownership by sourcing a creative developer with a dream; the redevelopment itself was made possible by a team of owners, investors, developers, designers, lenders, and construction professionals who saw an opportunity to breathe new life into a historic building and invest in Midtown’s future.

Looking for your next opportunity in Sacramento?

Whether you’re considering selling a commercial property, evaluating an investment, or exploring the potential of an underutilized building, Jacks Commercial Real Estate brings local knowledge, analytical experience, and a long-term perspective to the process.